Report: Australian consumers aren't happy with customer loyalty programs

New Accenture Strategy report looks at five key ingredients to building a strong customer loyalty program

Australian brands are wasting billions on customer loyalty programs that don’t work and aren’t keeping up to speed with the demands of modern consumers, a new report claims.

The report, Seeing beyond the loyalty illusion: It’s time you invest more wisely, was based on Accenture Strategy’s global pule research across more than 25,000 consumers globally including 1343 in Australia.

It found more than half of Australian consumers have switched brand or providers in the past year, while 79 per cent are retracting loyalty more quickly than they did three years ago. Globally, 71 per cent of respondents said current customer loyalty programs do not engender loyalty, and 23 per cent demonstrated a negative or non-existent reaction to loyalty efforts.

But those brands who do loyalty right are winning. For example, 58 per cent of Australian consumers spend more with the brands they love, and 49 per cent will recommend brands or organisations to which they are loyal to family and friends. As a result, 26 per cent said brands should do everything possible to earn their loyalty.

Based on the findings, the Accenture report outlines five key components to building customer loyalty in the modern age. Top of the list is ‘tokens of affection’, or providing personalised discounts, gift cards and special offers that reward a customer’s loyalty. According to the report, 56 per cent of Australian consumers feel loyal to brands that present such tokens to them.

The second tip was ‘get to know me’. The report found 38 per cent of local consumers are loyal to brands that offer the opportunity to personalise products and gain access to something bespoke, while 46 per cent gave a big tick to brands communicating with them through their preferred channel of communication. In addition, 73 per cent felt more loyal to brands that are there when they needed them.

However, by the same token, 81 per cent are more loyal to brands that safeguard and protect their privacy.

Accenture’s third tip was ‘thrill seeker’, or providing an opportunity to co-create and collaboration on products and services. More than four in 10 local consumers said they are loyal to brands that engage them to help design or co-create products or services, while 36 per cent prefer brands offering new experiences, products or services. New technologies also made an appearance here, with 27 per cent of consumers saying they are loyal to brands that offer multi-sensory experiences, using new offering such as augmented and virtual reality.

Fourth on the musts for brands was ‘If you like it, I like it’, or reflecting the consumer’s own personal preferences around celebrities, social influencers and close friends and family. For example, 17 per cent of Australian consumers said they are loyal to brands that partner with celebrities, and 34 per cent show loyalty to brands that actively support shared causes such as charities or public campaigns.

Accenture’s fifth tip was ‘hook me up’, or giving consumers the ability to connect to other providers to exchange loyalty points or rewards.

“Organisations need to understand the loyalty languages of their most profitable customers and implement the optimal mix to ensure they’re delivering the experiences that drive advocacy, retention and growth,” said Accenture Strategy managing director, Luca Martini. “An appetite for extraordinary, multi-sensory experiences, hyper-personalisation and co-creation, are changing consumer dynamics around loyalty and forcing brands and organisations to shift their approaches and programs.”

A recent report released by Nielsen also found consumers are more likely to return to a retailer if they have a strong customer loyalty program in place. More than half the Australian consumers surveyed (57 per cent) are more likely to return to a retailer with a loyalty program, and 48 per cent will spend more if they know they’re going to be rewarded.

Follow CMO on Twitter: @CMOAustralia, take part in the CMO conversation on LinkedIn: CMO ANZ, join us on Facebook:, or check us out on

Join the newsletter!

Error: Please check your email address.
Show Comments

Blog Posts

How can a brand remain human in a digital world?

Some commentators estimate that by 2020, 85 per cent of buyer-seller interactions will happen online through social media and video*. That’s only two years away, and pertinent for any marketer.

James Kyd

Global head of brand strategy and marketing, Xero

​Relevance and substance are the keys to marketing’s future

Marketing’s evolution and increased value-add to organisations is making headway in one essential direction: Driving brands to achieve maximum relevance in the heart and minds of customers.

Jean-Luc Ambrosi

Author, marketer

Why doing your job well is the key to innovation

The words ‘power company’ and ‘innovation’ probably don’t seem like a natural combination. In fact, when I first went for a marketing role with an electricity company, I semi-dreaded the work I thought I’d be doing.

Catherine Anderson

Head of marketing, Powershop Australia

It needs to come from the top. It's not just about buy-in from the leadership team, leadership should be part of the development process ...

Stephen Houraghan

Why getting intimate is key to creating a great customer experience and optimising customer value

Read more

When was this article posted?


Report Reveals the Channels That Really Influence Consumer Purchase Decisions

Read more

sorry, I did not see that my first attempt already posted.


5 ways Australian Unity is driving innovation

Read more

Examples of their "innovation": have had problems with them in their "innova...


5 ways Australian Unity is driving innovation

Read more

Examples of their "innovation": have had problems with them in other spheres.


5 ways Australian Unity is driving innovation

Read more

Latest Podcast

More podcasts

Sign in