Facebook undervalued in last-click attribution model: Report

New Kenshoo research finds social networking platform is undervalued by up to 30 per cent in a last ad attribution model against other types of custoemr attribution techniques

Marketers who use last ad attribution to measure Facebook’s brand impact as part of a multi-channel campaign are devaluing the social network’s impact and making flawed marketing decisions, a new report claims.

According to the Quantifying the Impact of Multi-touch Attribution research paper from digital marketing technology company, Kenshoo, the last ad model undervalues Facebook advertising by 12-30 per cent compared to five other industry standard alternative attribution models: First only, prefer first, divide equally, prefer last and U-Shaped.

While criticism of last ad attribution has grown in recent years, it remains widely used by marketers globally. There has also been insufficient data to backup the flaws in such an approach, the Kenshoo report stated.

Kenshoo analysed campaign performance data across its clients managing ads across multiple digital marketing channels between March and May. The company employed a cost-per-acquisition metric across all advertisers, which was calculated by aggregating all recorded conversions and dividing that number in the total media cost of the ads which drove them.

Kenshoo’s clients include Expedia, Hitwise, John Lewis, Starcom MediaVest Group, Tesco and Travelocity.

The research found Facebook was undervalued by 30 per cent using a last ad technique compared with a first only approach, where credit is only given to the first customer interaction. It was also undervalued by 20 per cent in a last ad model when contrasted with a prefer first approach, where the first customer touch gets the majority of the credit, and each following interaction is credited less in a rules-based, linear way.

Looking at Facebook’s worth using last-click attribution was also undervalued by 16 per cent against a divide equally technique, where the value of each touch is equal to the rest; and 15 per cent undervalued compared with a u-shaped approach, which uses an 80:20 rule to give the first and last click majority weighting and the middle clicks less credit.

A prefer last approach gives the last click most credit, followed in a linear fashion by the second-last touch. Against this example, Facebook was undervalued by 12 per cent in a last ad approach.

“Marketers relying on last ad attribution to optimise their campaigns could be making million-dollar decisions based on flawed data; so they can expect to achieve flawed results,” said Josh Dreller, director of marketing research at Kenshoo. “Multi-touch techniques better reflect the reality of consumer behaviour and enable marketers to improve budget allocation and campaign performance.”

Kenshoo’s findings echo those of a review of Google US Analytics ecommerce tracking accounts earlier this year, which claimed social media was the second most used channel after display ads in the earlier part of the purchasing process.

It is also backed up by the findings of a recent Aggregate Knowledge report, which found social continues to deliver the highest quality users.

Follow CMO on Twitter: @CMOAustralia, take part in the CMO Australia conversation on LinkedIn: CMO Australia, or join us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/CMOAustralia Signup to CMO’s new email newsletter to receive your weekly dose of targeted content for the modern marketing chief.

Join the CMO newsletter!

Error: Please check your email address.
Show Comments

Supporting Association

Blog Posts

Three killer strategies for data-driven audience targeting

Audience targeting is becoming an increasingly sophisticated art through data. Here, we look at three ways you can drive better engagement through different types of data assets and sources.

Michael Bird

CEO, Social Garden

Artificial intelligence, machine learning and the science of customer engagement

There is no let up for today’s CMO who needs to be the master of an ever-increasing variety of trades. Digital changed the game years ago, and now the CMO must be a skilled publisher, technologist and data analyst.

Growing skills shortage could hold our industry back

Every few weeks, I see an article about the gaps and talent shortages across our industry, particularly in digital strategy and analytics skills.

Yes. But on this issue there seems to be concensus between the fringe and the majority. Here is the industry peak body singing from the...

Paul Smith

CMO interview: Marketing the wool off a sheep’s back

Read more

Social media has become common ground where brands and customers meet and greet and due to its increasing popularity users becomes demand...

Alex Martin

Marketers struggle to provide an enriching and engaging experience

Read more

is this a joke?

andre veerhuis

Ticketek: Modern marketing strategy is about treating people as people

Read more

can you provide Top 10 public relations agencies in Australia

Ethan437

6 ways marketers are using technology in content marketing

Read more

Very true about start-ups changing the mentality of marketing. Ultimately, being quick, and adaptive is a great way to get ahead.

Estia

Are startups disrupting the traditional business model?

Read more

Latest Podcast

More podcasts

Sign in