The forgotten art of Acceptor/Rejector Analysis

Zac Martin

  • Planning director, Ogilvy Melbourne
  • Website
Zac is a planning director at Ogilvy Melbourne. For more than a decade he’s worked with brands big and small to help them find what they fight for, and turn business problems into advertising and communications strategy. He writes at Pigs Don’t Fly.

The way we analyse brand health market research is wrong.  

You survey a sample of the target audience to better understand your brand funnel (awareness, consideration and so on) and brand perceptions. The latter helps you understand how much people associate different attributes with your brand.  

Normally it looks like something like this example. Sometimes it’s presented in a fancy spider chart.  


The problem with brand associations  

When presented with the data above, you might make a decision to double down on your strength (Perception A) or focus to repair a weakness (Perception E). Or, if you compare the same attributes with competitors, you might identify white space to go after that.  

But there’s two issues with this. Firstly, it doesn’t tell you which perceptions matter to consumers. Your brand might have strong associations with ‘is a brand you can share with friends’. But this perception might be meaningless in influencing decisions. Likewise, you may under-index in ‘is an Australian brand’, but there’s no value in addressing it.  

It’s not uncommon to have complementary research where you ask consumers which factors matter to them when making a purchase. But we know what people say and what people do are almost always different. 

Secondly, the brand associations above are averages. This data includes both your most loyal heavy buyers, and those who despise you. Hardly useful.  

Analysing the differences  

To overcome these issues, we do Acceptor/Rejector Analysis. Rather than looking at brand associations as whole, we split the data into two cohorts:  

People who are aware of you but not buyers, let’s call them Rejectors. And buyers, let’s call them - Buyers.  

To turn the Rejectors into Buyers, we look at what makes them different. And we close the gap.  Here’s what the same data above looks like when it’s split out:  


We’re less interested in the absolute numbers of each cohort, but rather, the biggest gap between them.  

In the case above, a new insight emerges. Perception C was something we’d ignored to date - not quite a weakness and not quite a strength. Once we split it across the two cohorts, however, we see it is our most polarising brand association. The biggest difference between Buyers and Rejectors is the one we want to focus on.  

So, you would build a campaign to tackle Perception C.  

The best part of this insight? This analysis you can often do for free using an old brand health study. No extra cost, just 15 minutes to cut the data in a new way.  

Watchouts

There’s two things to keep in mind when looking at the gaps. Firstly, sometimes people have a good reason to reject your brand. If you’re a brewery you probably aren’t interested in perceptions among Coeliacs. Avoid this by filtering responses for people who aware of you AND who don’t buy you AND who buy your competitors.  

Second, as Jon Bradshaw reminded me, behaviour isn’t linear. People don’t always think or feel first, then act. Often, it’s the other way around – your thoughts and feelings change after you take action. Cognitive dissonance means we’re great at post rationalising, and why some suggest the fastest way to change behaviour is action first, then thoughts and feelings take care of themselves.  

As George Box said: “All models are wrong, but some are useful”.  

Tags: brand strategy, marketing campaigns, marketing analytics

Show Comments
cmo-xs-promo

Featured Whitepapers

State of the CMO 2021

CMO’s State of the CMO is an annual industry research initiative aimed at gauging how ...

More whitepapers

Latest Videos

More Videos

I couldn't understand one things why on earth people only talk aboutimpact of digital transformation on banking and finance field instead...

Rajesh Acharya

Digital take-up and experiences help drive Suncorp's solid FY21 performance

Read more

I really appreciate your article. Love your Article. By reading your article, its created an idea in my mind about loyalty strategy to ke...

Jack Reacher

Report: Marketers failing to realise the benefits of customer loyalty programs

Read more

One month’s research and we’ve handpicked this generation’s 50 most talented Women CEOs, leading the top multinational companies around t...

Vaishnavi Pillai

Women in leadership the focus on International Women’s Day

Read more

Great post!

deen8

What felix Mobile is doing to keep customer support cost-effective

Read more

That is true, integration of salesforce and digital advertising would make wonders.This can actually help firms to measure and evaluate t...

Neelam

Salesforce debuts first digital marketing enhancements off the back of Krux acquisition

Read more

Blog Posts

When friction can be a brand’s best friend

I always enjoy those oft-forgotten, in-between moments in any experience. These moments are not necessarily part of any defined experience per se. They likely wouldn’t show up in an organisation’s plans or ideas to help make the customer journey or user flow as simple, easy and seamless as possible.

Rich Curtis

CEO, FutureBrand A/NZ

How much attention should we be paying to the ‘attention economy’?

There’s been a lot of buzz in the advertising industry lately about what’s coined the ‘attention economy’. And it’s fast becoming the new battleground for media channels to prove their wares and to develop and espouse new attention metrics.

Nickie Scriven

CEO, Zenith

Sometimes the best solutions are some of the most counterintuitive

Exceptional CMOs do exceptional things for themselves and for those they inspire. At your best you are creative, innovative and inspirational. We have a problem though. We now live in a corporate world that demands sensibility where everything you do is measurable and stakeholders demand predictability – the antithesis of breakthrough and transformation.

Hamish Thomson

Author, former regional president and global brand head, Mars Incorporated

Sign in