Designing for a cashless society

Katja Forbes

Katja is an Australian pioneer in the field of experience design and all its components.Back in 2014, Katja founded syfte, a specialist business in research and experience design acquired by Wipro in 2018. She was then appointed Australian MD of Designit. Katja was also a co-founding member of the Interaction Design Association Board (IxDA) in Sydney, helping build a community of over 1600 designers. Today, Katja is international director on IxDA’s global board. Katja is a sought-after speaker for organisations including Women In Design, Leaders in Heels, Women In Commerce, Code like a Girl, Telstra and Macquarie Bank. Katja was recognised as a Top 10 Australian Women Entrepreneurs 2018 by My Entrepreneur Magazine and one of the 100 Women of Influence by Westpac and the Australian Financial Review in 2016.

More movement has been made toward a cashless society recently, and already we are starting to see enormous implications across our society.  

However, in a move that was meant to create greater freedom for us, it seems to have also directly interfered with our right to choose.  

For generations, money has always been the currency for which we bartered. It makes sense to have something to exchange for service rendered or items purchased, and is a great motivator for people to maintain employment and for the wheels of society to keep turning.  

However, nowadays it isn’t just the Queen who doesn’t carry cash. There are many benefits to both the customer and the seller for cards to be accepted in the interaction. Not only can small change be fiddly, but we can only spend a finite amount (if we have $10 in our wallet we can only spend that, whereas a bank card allows expenditure of any amounts without it necessarily being physically present.)  

Credit cards, on the other hand, are much more likely to create over-spending, as their limits are higher and you can spend money you don’t even have.  

Over the past few years, currency itself and the way we shop has evolved with both positive and negative effects. Mobile paying systems completely reduce the requirement of having to manually insert or enter your credit card details each time. Yet unlike when we spend cash, our spending patterns can be observed at a later time.  

On the one hand, it is handy for us to understand where our money went during the past month each time read our statement, but it is also important to realise this information can be accessed by any number of people. Your partner can view your statement to find out where you have been spending all your money each month, but the reality extends past your family members.  

If you want to apply for a home loan, lenders are currently clamping down and getting a loan can be very challenging. Your bank statements will be viewed by the lender, and in this case, if you are spending a lot on electronics, gadgets or make-up, this will not look favourable on your application. Cash withdrawals from ATMs in pubs with poker machines could be viewed as gambling behaviour.  

Aside from that, consider that banks and stores are accessing your spending data (not your credit card details – these are secure) but it can certainly feel upsetting. For this reason, your identity will be reduced to statistics, but nobody likes to feel Big Brother is watching.  

Just as a cashless society has moulded our spending behaviour, so too has it directly affected homeless people. Along with street artists and buskers, homeless people are helped by the generosity of those who pass by. Once you had handed them a coin, you may immediately wonder if they will use that money for something to eat, or booze and cigarettes. You never know for sure, but you have empowered that person by giving them the right to choose – something we all are provided with as human beings.   

Now, however, the currency they ‘accept’ is used less and less. More often, we are leaving home with little or no cash in our wallet, and make transactions with our cards or mobile. Therefore, there is nothing to give to the homeless.  

With this problem in mind, someone clever has invented an app we can use to donate money to the homeless. It has functionality allowing it to identify the person we would like to donate to by scanning a QR code they display, and instead of collecting the cash and giving it to each of them accordingly, the donations are sent to a local ‘hub’. The recipient needs to access this hub, where he/she will be met by an adviser, and the homeless person can discuss their ideas for the future, and collect his/her money. The Greater Change app is now being tested in the UK city of Oxford.  

While the inventor of this app obviously has good intentions, it is so easy to see how this cashless society has caused our freedom to choose to be eroded and Big Brother’s influence is growing. There is no doubt the App was created to offer a greater future for the homeless. But the very means they have used has also inadvertently removed their freedom of choice, and as such, risks making them feel like children asking for permission to receive the money they have been kindly given and needing to discuss their future intentions before they can spend it.  

Add to that the dubious action of scanning a human like they’re an object and the discomfort becomes greater. But does the ends of getting money to that person in some way justify the means?  

A cashless society certainly has worthwhile benefits. But as designers, we need to consider ways we can allow consumers the benefits of not having to constantly draw cash out the ATM, yet not penalise those who don’t participate in the banking system due to social exclusion or disadvantage. Our design decisions always have unintended consequences. What’s convenient for some can be devastating for others.  

Tags: design thinking, customer experience managament

Show Comments

Featured Whitepapers

State of the CMO 2020

CMO’s State of the CMO is an annual industry research initiative aimed at understanding how ...

State of the CMO 2019

CMO’s State of the CMO is an annual industry research initiative aimed at understanding how ...

More whitepapers

Latest Videos

Conversations over a cuppa with CMO: Microsoft's Pip Arthur

​In this latest episode of our conversations over a cuppa with CMO, we catch up with the delightful Pip Arthur, Microsoft Australia's chief marketing officer and communications director, to talk about thinking differently, delivering on B2B connection in the crisis, brand purpose and marketing transformation.

More Videos

Did anyone proofread this document before it was published?

Beau Ushay

CMO Momentum 2020: How to embrace agile marketing

Read more

he decision to limit the initial version of the code to two US companies is discriminatory and will inevitably give an unfair advantage t...

Azeem Sohail

Google hits out at ACCC draft code of conduct for news media negotiations

Read more

You’re a warrior woman from way back. Just let the muscle memory take over!

Hannah Sturrock

Why fear trumps marketing theory - Marketing edge - CMO Australia

Read more

What an inspiring piece of writing, Hannah, thank you so much for sharing! All right, team jersey out of the locker, brains on, eye of th...

Myriam Conrie

Why fear trumps marketing theory - Marketing edge - CMO Australia

Read more

Thanks for the post

Ashirwad Towers

How a brand facelift and content strategy turned real estate software, Rockend, around

Read more

Blog Posts

A Brand for social justice

In 2020, brands did something they’d never done before: They spoke up about race.

Dipanjan Chatterjee and Xiaofeng Wang

VP and principal analyst and senior analyst, Forrester

Determining our Humanity

‘Business as unusual’ is a term my organisation has adopted to describe the professional aftermath of COVID-19 and the rest of the tragic events this year. Social distancing, perspex screens at counters and masks in all manner of situations have introduced us to a world we were never familiar with. But, as we keep being reminded, this is the new normal. This is the world we created. Yet we also have the opportunity to create something else.

Katja Forbes

Managing director of Designit, Australia and New Zealand

Should your business go back to the future?

In times of uncertainty, people gravitate towards the familiar. How can businesses capitalise on this to overcome the recessionary conditions brought on by COVID? Craig Flanders explains.

Craig Flanders

CEO, Spinach

Sign in