R3: Transparency is triggering a disconnect between agency and CMO

Co-founder of global marketing effectiveness consultancy says short-termism and drastically reduced CMO tenure are behind the growing disconnect between brands and agencies


It’s well over 100 years since American merchant, John Wanamaker, once opined his ignorance regarding which half of his marketing budget was wasted.

The passage of time appears to have done little to bring succour to his latter-day peers when it comes to accountability in their marketing spending.

This age-old problem was recast in a whole new light in October last year when the US FBI contacted the Association of National Advertisers to offer its assistance in an investigation into US media buying practices. This came off the back of years of concern regarding non-transparent business practices such as undisclosed rebates.

According to co-founder and principal consultant at global marketing effectiveness consultancy R3, Greg Paull, the involvement of the FBI has fuelled advertisers’ desire for greater transparency into how their money is being spent.

“If you look at something like a programmatic media spend, and the money that is lost along the way from the $100 you invest to the $30 or $40 that ends up running, that has really been the impetus for a lot of marketers to take a closer look at this whole process,” Paull tells CMO.

R3 works with brands and brand-houses including Procter & Gamble, Unilever and Samsung to reduce the risks of marketing through use of benchmarks, transparency and best practice. Speaking ahead of his appearance at the Institute of Internal Auditor’s SOPAC conference in Sydney in March, Paull says the current trend towards short-term thinking and the rapid turnover of CMOs may actually be exacerbating the problem.

“One of the biggest issues is the constant change of agency relationships, through CMO turnover and agency turnover. It has been very difficult for a lot of brands to build longevity,” he says. “If you look at people like Unilever and others, they have had 100-year relationships with some of their agencies. It means you have very consistent custodianship of brand leadership. A lot of other companies don’t have that structure and opportunity.”

Paull says the rise of short-termism has been driven both by marketing teams that want to place the blame for poor performance outside their own organisation, and agencies that are now slaved to quarterly returns.

“Agencies that are now public companies are more and more focused on their business, than necessarily as an agency to the client,” Paull says. “Both those factors are causing a disconnect.”

This set of circumstances has been further impacted by the greater prominence of procurement departments in selecting and managing agency relationships, which is leading to more reviews.

“Some of them are becoming cyclical now, happening every two or three years just as a matter of course, which is a big challenge,” Paull says.

While agencies might be restricted in their ability to influence the policies of their clients, Paull says there is much they can achieve by focusing back on their clients as true business partners and not just as a source of revenue.

“That means looking at what proactively can be done to help them innovate and grow as opposed to just answering a brief,” he continues. “Too often agencies will get lumped with a comms brief, whereas a CMO is being judged on a business brief. So trying to take it up to a higher order can only help.”

Paull says agencies would also help their cause if they insisted on third-party accountability, and some agencies in the US are outsourcing 100 per cent of post analysis.

“It doesn’t make sense for agencies to be marking their own homework,” he says. “Where you have a grown-up agency that can make those kinds of calls is only going to reflect favourably on them.”

Paull says another area that bears closer examination is the KPIs being applied in agency relationships.

“They are not focused on growth and innovation,” Paull says. “They are more focused on year-on-year improvement, or more static numbers. They are certainly not looking at encouraging failure and rewarding failure.”

Ultimately, he says the current frustration with transparency is being driven by clients who are trying to break free of constrained growth, and are looking for better accountability for their spend.

“You can’t move what you can’t measure and there is still a lot of short-termism in a lot of marketing strategies and a lot of reflective work coming from competitors,” Paull adds. “Everyone is searching for that Holy Grail, and it is not easy to find that solution to marketing accountability. But it is a constant journey rather than a single solution.”

Follow CMO on Twitter: @CMOAustralia, take part in the CMO conversation on LinkedIn: CMO ANZ, join us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/CMOAustralia, or check us out on Google+:google.com/+CmoAu   

 

Join the newsletter!

Or

Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.
Show Comments

Latest Videos

Conversations over a cuppa with CMO: Microsoft's Pip Arthur

​In this latest episode of our conversations over a cuppa with CMO, we catch up with the delightful Pip Arthur, Microsoft Australia's chief marketing officer and communications director, to talk about thinking differently, delivering on B2B connection in the crisis, brand purpose and marketing transformation.

More Videos

Great content and well explained. Everything you need to know about Digital Design, this article has got you covered. You may also check ...

Ryota Miyagi

Why the art of human-centred design has become a vital CX tool

Read more

Interested in virtual events? If you are looking for an amazing virtual booth, this is definitely worth checking https://virtualbooth.ad...

Cecille Pabon

Report: Covid effect sees digital events on the rise long-term

Read more

Thank you so much for sharing such an informative article. It’s really impressive.Click Here & Create Status and share with family

Sanwataram

Predictions: 14 digital marketing predictions for 2021

Read more

Nice!https://www.live-radio-onli...

OmiljeniRadio RadioStanice Uzi

Google+ and Blogger cozy up with new comment system

Read more

Awesome and well written article. The examples and elements are good and valuable for all brand identity designs. Speaking of awesome, ch...

Ryota Miyagi

Why customer trust is more vital to brand survival than it's ever been

Read more

Blog Posts

A Brand for social justice

In 2020, brands did something they’d never done before: They spoke up about race.

Dipanjan Chatterjee and Xiaofeng Wang

VP and principal analyst and senior analyst, Forrester

Determining our Humanity

‘Business as unusual’ is a term my organisation has adopted to describe the professional aftermath of COVID-19 and the rest of the tragic events this year. Social distancing, perspex screens at counters and masks in all manner of situations have introduced us to a world we were never familiar with. But, as we keep being reminded, this is the new normal. This is the world we created. Yet we also have the opportunity to create something else.

Katja Forbes

Managing director of Designit, Australia and New Zealand

Should your business go back to the future?

In times of uncertainty, people gravitate towards the familiar. How can businesses capitalise on this to overcome the recessionary conditions brought on by COVID? Craig Flanders explains.

Craig Flanders

CEO, Spinach

Sign in